to Samira Ayoub,

Winner of the 2023 Bud Boucher Memorial Scholarship.

Free speech is a cornerstone of American democracy and a fundamental human right that is protected by the First Amendment to our Constitution. However, in recent years, we have seen a growing trend of individuals seeking to limit free speech and ban speech that makes others uncomfortable. This trend, known as “woke” or “cancel culture”, is a clear antithesis to the First Amendment and threatens to undermine one of the most important pillars of our society. What I want to make clear, is that there are many important discussions being raised under the “woke” banner that society should address and have a reasonable discourse. However, “woke” culture's emphasis on policing language and ideas deemed offensive or harmful can lead to a culture of self-censorship and restrict the free expression of ideas, potentially infringing on the First Amendment rights of individuals.


The problem with “cancel culture” is that it creates an environment where individuals are afraid to express their opinions openly. This leads to a chilling effect on free speech, where individuals self-censor themselves, afraid of the potential backlash from the “cancel culture” mob.


During a family discussion on this topic, my father shared with me an example about Galileo that I would like to share with you. Galileo's persecution is a perfect example of how “cancel culture” can be detrimental to free speech. Galileo was a brilliant scientist who challenged the widely held belief that the earth was the center of the universe. His ground-breaking work was considered too controversial and threatened the existing power structures of the time. As a result, he was silenced and persecuted by the authorities.


Galileo's persecution shows us that “cancel culture” can stifle innovation and progress by silencing dissenting voices. It limits the free flow of ideas and the exchange of information, which is essential for a functioning democracy. This type of behavior can be dangerous and prevent us from addressing critical issues facing our society.


Furthermore, “cancel culture” can lead to groupthink, where only certain ideas are allowed to be expressed, and dissenting voices are silenced. This type of environment can be detrimental to a democratic society, as it limits our ability to challenge the status quo, innovate, and grow.

The First Amendment protects our right to free speech, and it is essential that we defend this right. We must resist any efforts to limit free speech, even if we disagree with the ideas being expressed. We must have open and honest discussions about important issues facing our society, even if these discussions make us uncomfortable.


It is crucial to remember that free speech is not just about protecting speech that we agree with, but also about protecting speech that we disagree with. It is through these discussions and debates that we can learn from one another and grow as a society.


Bud Boucher.

The Bud Boucher Memorial Scholarship was established to honor the memory of Bud Boucher a longtime resident of Wilton, who loved America, was intensely interested in the political process, and was committed to participating as an engaged, informed citizen.

Learn more about Bud.